Showing posts with label Ontario. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Ontario. Show all posts

Saturday, February 4, 2012

Muskoka Bay Club Course Review

Muskoka Bay Club
Gravenhurst, Ontario, Canada

Architect: Doug Carrick (2006)

7,367 Yards, Par 72

Rating/Slope: 76.1/146

My Quick Review: A very scenic golf course with many thrilling shots, but several long forced carries, an unwalkable routing and a few too many downhill tee shots keep this course from my list of favourites.

My Thoughts

Since opening a half-dozen years ago, the golf course at The Muskoka Bay Club has received many awards.  It is ranked no. 8 in Canada by Score Golf Magazine and no. 5 Modern by Golfweek Magazine.  While I think the golf course is good, I do not see it among the best golf courses in Canada.  Unlike some of my favourite modern courses in Ontario, such as Rocky Crest, Bigwin Island and Beacon Hall, I am not sure MBC holds its strategic interest after multiple plays.

MBC is the epitome of modern golf.  There are many dramatic views and exciting tee shots.  The course is not walkable (OK, it is possible to walk, but as I found out, walking makes for a far less enjoyable experience).  The routing is similar to that of Wolf Creek (Nevada) in that walkability was sacrificed for beauty and vistas.  It felt like Carrick knew the course would not be walked and as a result found the best 18 holes and used them, whether or not there were tough climbs to tees or long treks around hazards.  


But, this also contributed to MBC's natural feeling.  If there was significant amount of land moved to build the golf course, I couldn't tell.  The holes were there just waiting for Carrick to find them.  A big part of the natural feel of the golf course is the wonderfully rolling and undulating fairways.  Only a couple were flattened (1 and 5), but the rest are "wild and super cool."  


Also, of particular note, is the extremely contoured 8th green.  Though I am sure some consider this green 'goofy golf,' I think it is the best green on the course and it is completely natural, mimicking the rock formation upon which it is built. 


Holes to Note

All yardages from Gold tees (second from back).

Hole 1: Par 4, 392 Yards - "Table Rock"
The first tee shot may be the most difficult on the course.  Playing downhill and into the wind, a forced carry of around 225 yards is required just to reach the fairway (it's 272 yards from the tips!!).  Although most are probably solely concerned with reaching the fairway, one must be careful not to miss right as there is hazard all the way down the right.  The bunkers are a long way from the tee and I would think are only in play for the longest of hitters.  One thing I noticed at MB is that in some cases the bunkers, rather than adding strategic interest, were often used as a means to frame a hole ('eye candy').
1st Back Tee
1st Gold Tee
1st Short of Fairway - Note hazard on right, not much room to miss on 1 tee!
1st Green
1st from Behind

Hole 2 : Par 3, 181 yards - "Pulpit"
A very strong par 3.  It is not obvious from the tee, but the green is actually quite large and has quite a bit of movement.  There is a bit of a false front. The green also extends back left meaning a back left pen will look like it is floating in the rough.  A very cool visual.  Short and especially short right are dead!
Tee View
Green from Right
Short of Green
Green

Hole 3: Par 4, 399 Yards - "Lost Lake"
My favorite hole on the course!  There is a diagonal ridge in the fairway that MUST be carried if one wants to have any sort of view of the green.  From the tees I played, it is around 210 yards to carry the ridge down the middle, a fair bit less if you bail right and a fair bit more if you take the aggressive line up the left.  There is a very big difference in the approach from a tee shot that fails to carry the ridge.  The shot is blind and the green is clearly designed to be approached from the right.  Short of the green a ridge on the right will assist a player coming in from the left.
Tee View
View from Left of Ridge (Tee Shot that does not carry ridge)
Approach from Right
View from Behind

Hole 8: Par 5, 494 Yards - "Eiger"
Another very pretty golf hole from an elevated tee.  This hole is reachable in two for most, especially if you are willing to challenge the right side fairway bunker.  Looks can be deceiving, however, as one must not attempt to bite off too much as it is around 280 yards to get over the whole bunker.
Tee View
Tee View Zoomed
From the DZ (driving zone), one must choose whether or not to try to reach the green in two.  There is trouble left and a large up slope to the green, meaning any shots just short will leave a difficult third.  Part of the reason I really liked this hole was that most players will have the ammo to get to the green in two, but it is one of those situations where, on average, you will definitely score better by hitting 8 iron, wedge.
View from DZ
Approach from 70 Yards Out
Left of Green (Yep, That's My Ball)
The 8th green is the boldest green on the course.  The front portion sloped towards the front creating a false front that, if found, could leave the ball some 30 yards from the green.  The back portion of the green is divided into distinct sections by a large ridge.
Green from Front
Green from Back-Right
Green from Behind

Hole 9: Par 4, 390 Yards - "The Narrows"
One of the most dramatic holes you will ever see.  A very downhill tee shot (with a forced carried over hazard - about 220 yards) to a reasonably wide fairway.  The layout of the hole and the small grouping of trees right give you a clue that you really want to challenge the longer carry over the hazard and find the left side of the fairway.  However, it is not until you get down to the DZ that you see how big a difference it is to be on the correct side of the fairway.
Tee View
From the right, the green is completely hidden from view.  From the left, one can see the top of the pin and a small piece of the green.  Only a golfer that has been to MB before has any idea what awaits behind the rocks.
Approach from Right
Approach from Left
The green is very wide and shallow.  Rather than surprise the player by what is found over the rocks, Carrick designed a wide enough green that anything (line-wise) close to a good shot should find the putting surface.
View from Behind
Hole 11: Par 3, 173 Yards - "Bad Baby"
A stunning little par 3.  One of those holes that makes you go "wow" when you see it.  But this is no gimme.  Despite all the room around the green, the fairly severe slopes surrounding the green make this target feel much smaller than it actually is.  I can imagine many players tensing up on this tee.

The slope of the green allows a player several ways to get the ball close a pin tucked over the bunker.
Tee View
Tee View Zoomed
Green
Hole 12: Par 5, 539 Yards - "Alps"
Despite its yardage, this one is reachable in two.  This is one of the most undulating fairways you will ever see.  The rocks in the center of the fairway are a bit of visual deception.  A tee shot anywhere right of the rocks will use the fairway undulations to kick forward and toward the center of the fairway.  However, a tee shot over the fairway to the left of the rock will find trouble, even though this appears to be the preferred/aggressive line on this hole that gently moves left.
Tee View
Anything left of the rick will find more rock, thick rough and severe slopes right to left (making the lay-up, with water left, more difficult).
Tee Shots in the Left Side of the Fairway Will Kick into Rough/Rocks
The bunker short-right of the green has a kind of floating feeling.  I'm not sure it really comes into play or impacts strategy.  Eye-candy again?
Approach from Left
12th as Seen from 14th Fairway

Hole 14: Par 5, 560 Yards - "Himalayas"
Another very dramatic tee shot.  The rocks are certainly in play on this one.  The aggressive line over the rocks requires a carry of about 230 yards, though it does not yield a significantly advantage as just about everyone will be laying up.
14th Tee
The second shot provides few visual clues, but fortunately the layup is relatively straightforward.  A blind shot with no trickery.
View from Fairway
The approach into the green can lull the player into a false sense of security. Even from as close as 100 yards out, a deep valley just short left of the green is completely hidden from view.  The front right of the green is protected by a severe false front.
Approach from 100 Yards
A Deep Gulley Guards the Front of the Green
View from Behind

Hole 15: Par 4, 445 Yards - "Alcatraz"
A long par 4 largely defined by the tee shot.  Any approach from the right side of the fairway will likely be blocked out by a large tree.  The player is forced to challenge the left side of the fairway, but a severe left to right cant makes it difficult to have a ball remain on the left.  The slope can be used as a bit of a 'speed slot' to gain extra yardage off the tee.
Tee View
Approach from Right
Approach from Left

Hole 17: Par 3, 214 Yards - "Waterloo"
The difficult stretch of holes coming home continues with 17.  A do-or-die par-3 playing over 200 yards, and often into the wind.  From the the tee, the green looks almost unhittable.  Nevertheless, a good tee shot is rewarded as the green slopes back-to-front and will receive a shot from a long-iron/hybrid.  A ridge at the back portion of the green can be used to help collect a tee-shot to the difficult back-right pin position.  I have never played a back right pin, but I imagine it would be very intimidating from the tee.  
Tee View
Drop-Zone View
Green from Right
Green from Behind

Thursday, February 2, 2012

Essex Golf and Country Club Review

Essex Golf and Country Club 
LaSalle, Ontario, Canada

Architect: Donald Ross (1929)

6,703 Yards, Par 71

Rating/Slope: 72.6/132

My Quick Review: Too often dismissed because of its flat land -- Essex has one of the best bunkering schemes and one of the strongest sets of greens in the country.

My Thoughts

Essex has undergone many changes since the late 1920s, but in general the Club has remained committed to maintaining the orignal Ross design.  In the 1970s/80s, Arthur Hills added bunkering (which sticks out), as well as an additional irrigation pond that is in play on the 11th and 13th holes (the only other water in play, a pond on the 8th, is original).  Around the turn of the century, the Club hired Renaissance Golf Design to restore the greens and bunkering.  A lot of credit is due to Mr. Chris Andejicka, the Club's Superintendent, who has trimmed the trees that threatened to choke the fairway corridors.

I hope you enjoy the photos, but in truth, Essex is a golf course that looks much better in person.  The subtle ground movements and great green contouring does not come through in pictures.  Nevertheless, Essex is flat-land golf course architecture at its best and is one of my favorite courses in the country.

Holes to Note

Hole 1: Par 4, 381 yards
A gentle opener, with a fairly scary bunker down the right side of the fairway.  The player has the option of laying up short of the bunker off the tee, leaving 160ish yards, or playing to the more narrow part of the fairway and taking on the fairway bunker.
1st Tee
Approach to a green with a small false front.  Bunkers left and right are a good 15 yards short of the green making the approach appear more difficult than it plays (this feature felt very common at Essex).
1st Approach - Note the Rumpled Fairway

Hole 3: Par 5, 523 yards
Hole 3 is a medium length, subtle dogleg right par 5.  OB threatens the whole way down the right side, though most shots likely will be caught in the trees rather than end up OB.  Fairway bunkers flank the fairway on the tee shot.  Any player hoping to get home in two must challenge the right hand bunker.
3rd Tee
The lay up leaves the player with options.  A fairway bunker on the right juts out into the fairway at approximately 150 yards from the green and a second fairway bunker narrows the fairway from the left at 100 yards out.  One must choose both their line and their lay up yardage carefully.
3rd Second Shot
Intimidating approach over a deep bunker, to a slightly elevated green where shots long or right will kick further away from the green.
3rd Approach
The green is very interesting and is bisected by a ridge through the middle of the green (that cannot be seen from the fairway).  The ridge is flattened by the photo, but if you are on the wrong side you are in trouble.
3rd Green

3rd from Behind
Hole 4: Par 4, 461 yards
Hole 4 is the beginning of a difficult three hole stretch.  Another dogleg right, although this is one is slightly more severe.  Once again, one must challenge the bunkers on the inside of the dogleg for a shorter approach to the green.  A pulled tee shot into the left rough will have a problem with overhanging limbs.  This hole was originally designed as a par-5 (yep back-to-back par-5s!).
4th Tee
The green allows a player to run a long approach shot on to the green, but one must beware of the false front.
4th Short of Green
Run offs to the right and back right of the green.
4th Green from Right

Hole 6: Par 4, 454 yards
Hole 6 is long, straight and difficult.  One of the few holes where fairway bunkers are not in play on the tee shot.
6th Tee
Although it is not clear in the picture, the hole has, I believe, three swales running across the fairway making for more interesting lies.
6th Fairway
Fairway bunkers flank the fairway 50 yards out, making for an interesting lay-up for those players that are unable to reach this long par 4 in two.
6th Short of Green

Hole 7: Par 3, 157 yards
One of my favorite holes on the golf course.  A beautiful short par 3, surrounded by 5 bunkers.  The green (sorry, no picture) has a very well-defined spine coming off the back of the green that splits the back portion of the green into two.  The hole, at first glance, reminded me quite a bit of #5 at Aronimink GC.



Hole 9: Par 4, 437 yards
A very strong par 4 with an intimidating tee shot.  From the tee, one is forced to choose either to attempt to carry the left fairway bunker or attempt to thread the needle.  The view from the tee makes it appear as though there is almost no room between the bunkers, but the fairway is probably 40 yards wide.  A clever visual trick.
9th Tee
A tee shot of ~200 yards would leave this impossible approach (green is around the corner, behind the trees on the left).
Approach from Left
Approach after an ideal tee shot.  Once again, bunkers well short of the green give the appearance of a more difficult approach.  I also like the location of the right hand bunkers, penalizing the player that was cautious off the tee and hit a tee shot that did not challenge the left side.
Approach from Centre
9th Green and Clubhouse

Hole 10: Par 5, 501 yards
A straight away par 5 with OB well right.  Bunkers on the left are approximately 270 yards off the tee and from looking at old pictures, they appear to be a fairly new addition.  The hole was likely at the mercy of longer hitters and these bunkers pinch the landing area for a long hitter while having minimal impact on the shorter hitters.  A great addition, in my opinion.
10th Tee
Second Shot from Short of Fairway Bunkers
Second Shot from Right of Fairway Bunkers
Very interesting lay-up shot with four bunkers defining the landing area.  Depending on the placement of the tee shot, the player must make a definitive decision on both line and distance on the lay up.
10th Approach
Picture taken from right of green.  Notice the small area at the bottom of the picture.  A phenomenal place for a Sunday pin position, tucked just over the greenside bunker.
10th Green


Hole 14: Par 4, 422 yards
Another difficult par 4.  The tee shot is flanked with bunkers on both sides of the fairway to catch an errant tee shot, but there is plenty of fairway width that the bunkers do not give the fairway a cramped feel.
14th Fairway
Approach once again features bunkers well short of the green.
14th Approach Right
14th Short of Green
I wish cameras could adequately capture the slope in the green.  There are several 'rolls' in the green that make this one of the most interesting and difficult greens I have ever seen.
14th Green

Hole 15: Par 4, 364 yards



15 and 16 are two excellent short par 4s that offer a chance for birdie before a very tough finish.  A set of bunkers cut into the fairway on the right around 240 yards from the tee.  One must choose whether or not to challenge them.  The decision is made more difficult by a very deep and intimidating front-right greenside bunker that is much more in play on a laid-up tee shot.
15th Tee
Approach from 150

It is clear that the further left one goes, the better the angle to the green, but some trees (not pictured) left of the fairway will serve to block out a tee shot that is hit too far left.
Approach from Left

Hole 16: Par 4, 388 yards
One of my favorite holes on the course.  Another mid-length par 4 that plays straightaway and forces the player to choose whether to challenge the right side fairway bunkers.
16th Tee
Approach from Lay-Up Tee Shot
Approach from Left of Fairway Bunkers

A large bunker crosses the fairway 25 yards short of the green.  From the fairway it is very difficult to tell that there is any room between the bunker and the green.  While it may seem like it should not be in play, don't tell that to my playing partners.
Cross-Bunker Short of Green
Lots of Room Between Cross-Bunker and Green