Showing posts with label Florida. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Florida. Show all posts

Friday, January 27, 2012

Crandon Golf Course Review

Crandon Golf Course 
Key Biscayne, Florida, United States

Architects: Robert Von Hagge & Bruce Devlin (1972)

Yardage: 7,354 Yards, Par 72

Rating/Slope: 76.5/151

My Quick Review: Interesting 'tournament style' greens but overall a disappointment with too many doglegs, bizarre mounding and a shortage of ocean views.

My Thoughts
The drive to Crandon GC is gorgeous.  Crossing over the Rickenbecker Causeway, I was treated to phenomenal views of downtown Miami and Biscayne Bay.  I had no idea if the golf course was any good, but hopes were high for at least a few jaw-dropping vistas.
View from Causeway
'Tournament Greens'
I have no idea if the golf course was designed with the intention of hosting professional golf tournaments in mind, but it certainly felt as though it was.  Many of the greens had little fingers and/or bowls.  On many greens I got the sense that Devlin/Von Hagge were thinking, "ok, Thursday pin on that finger on the left side of the green, Friday pin is the bowl at the back of the green..."  The greens were very formulaic.  This is not necessarily a bad thing, as some of these fingers/bowls make for some very fun pin positions, but it is something that should be noted.

Repetitive Doglegs
On many holes (1, 2, 4, 5, 7, 11, 13, 15, 16) the fairway doglegged around a series of bunkers/trees.  These holes look almost identical from the tee.  In each case the hole doglegs much more than it appears, and in each case taking an aggressive line gets you in trouble.  BORING! Below are the tee shots on a few holes, see the similarities?
1st Tee
2nd Tee
7th Tee
15th Tee
16th Tee
Bizarre Mounding
Framing was a very popular design style in the 1970s, and unfortunately, Crandon is plagued with many framing mounds.  Almost without fail, the greens are backed by bunkers benched into artificial mounding.  The intention is to give each hole a sense of isolation, but the result is a completely unnatural and artificial greensite.  A good example is below:
Mounding behind 12th Green
Runway Tees
This is not a huge one, but I am a fan of golf courses that differentiate the difficulty between sets of tees by using both length and varied teeing angles.  Donald Ross did an exceptional job of using different teeing angles at the Biltmore Resort Golf Course, but the runway teeing style used at Crandon does not do this at all.
A 100-Yard Long Runway Tee on the 13th
Scorecard Information


Holes to Note
Hole 3: Par 3, 193 Yards


After a forgettable start to the round, the 3rd hole is one to remember.  The tee shot on this par-3 requires the golfer 'thread the needle' and carry a water hazard to try to find a green that looks almost un-hittable.  There is a lot of visual deception here as the green is much larger than it appears, and the water hazard ends some 40 yards short of the green.  The green is also surrounded by bunkers, none of which are visible from the tee.
3rd Back Tee View
3rd Back Tee View Zoomed
The 3rd green is a good example of what I meant by 'tournament green.'  The green is interestingly shaped with a tongue front-right, one back-right and a bowl back-left.  So there you go, you have your Thursday-Sunday pins covered -- each of those sections and one centre pin.
3rd from Behind -- Note the Gaps in the Trees, those are the Teeing Areas!
Hole 8: Par 3, 140 Yards
This is an amazing par-3!  Somewhat reminiscent of Donald Ross' volcano green on the par-3 6th at CC of Buffalo, this green is one you shouldn't miss, but are in big trouble if you do. Visual intimidation is a big factor in the design of this hole -- though the green is large, the obvious penalty for missing makes this a nerve-wracking tee shot.  A very wide teeing area allows this hole to be played from a wide array of angles.  A tee shot from a point in-line with the centre of the green gives the golfer much more room to miss than one from either the left or the right.
8th Tee
Shots landing short will absolutely not bounce onto the green...
In fact, anything landing on the front 1/4 of the green is no good as there is a large false-front
Shots missing right will carom into this bunker leaving a very difficult recovery...
And missing long-right leaves an equally difficult recovery...
Lastly, missing left leaves a difficult pitch from a grass bunker...
The green is fairly flat, but it is hog-backed, making it even more difficult to hit.  Shots landing near the left or right edges of the green will kick off the green.
A remarkable golf hole.  Aim for the centre of the green and make sure you don't mishit it -- no problem, right?

Hole 11: Par 4, 450 Yards
OK, so most of this hole is ho-hum, but the green is one-of-a-kind.

With bunkers left and water right, this is not the easiest tee shot, but there isn't a whole lot of thinking either.  Anything in the fairway works.
11th Tee
The approach is played over water and bunkers to yet another push-up green.  With water right and bunkers short and left, there's nowhere to miss.
11th Approach
The green and surrounds are really interesting.  First is the bunker left of the green with a huge mound in its centre.  I called it the 'nose bunker' for obvious reasons.  I don't know that I've seen a bunker like this before.  Shots at the left edge of the green will kick into the bunker thanks to some very good mowing lines.
The 'Nose Bunker'
Shots will Collect into the 'Nose Bunker'
The green is an inverted Biarritz, with a centre portion that is raised several feet above the front and back lower portions.  I have never seen a green like this before.
11th Green from Front of Green
11th Green from Behind
11th Green from Left
Hole 12: Par 3, 187 Yards
This is a very difficult par-3, especially if the wind is blowing.  The edge of the green is only one-yard from the water's edge, and bunkers long prevent the golfer from bailing-out.  Get your yardage and line right...

12th Tee
12th Short of Green
 The 12th hole is a perfect example of the bizarre containment mounding found everywhere at Crandon.  On the bright side, the mounds gave me a nice spot to take pictures from...
12th from Behind
Hole 18: Par 5, 555 Yards
Ever wanted to tee-off from a chute like the 18th at Augusta National?  Well, here's your chance!  The tee shot on the 18th at Crandon may be the most difficult I have ever seen.  Trees and Biscayne Bay guard the right, it is a 250 yard carry over water to reach the fairway, and there is water left -- and the chute through which the golfer must hit the tee shot is unbelievably narrow.

18th Tee
18th Tee Zoomed
I was quite disappointed that even though Crandon is on an island, there are no views of the water.  Well, at least not until the 18th.  Though the water is not in play, there is a cut-out of the trees that gives way to this exceptional view of the Bay and downtown Miami:

OK, back to the golf.  The second shot must avoid the trees right and a bunker 100 yards short of the green on the left.  As far as I'm concerned, the bunker is unnecessary -- the hole is hard enough as is, but it is there and must be dealt with.
18th Second Shot
18th Approach
The final green is another example of a 'tournament green'.  The green snakes around bunkers short-left, short-right and long-right.  From the fairway, it is impossible to see the green shape.
Green from Front
Green from Right
Green from Behind
Green from Left

Monday, January 9, 2012

West Palm Beach Golf Club Review

West Palm Beach Municipal Golf Course
West Palm Beach, Florida, United States

Architect: Dick Wilson (1947), Restored by Mark McCumber (2009)

Yardage: 7,002 Yards, Par 72

Rating/Slope: 73.0/128

My Quick Review: Don't let the word 'muni' scare you away -- West Palm Beach GC was a long-time PGA tour stop and is one of the best values in the country.

My Thoughts


If you like courses that play firm and fast, then WPB is for you.  Of the 75 or so courses I've played in South Florida, only one (which must have a massive maintenance budget) had a maintenance meld that encouraged the ground-game like WPB.  Sure, the fairway grass is a bit thin in spots, the amount of sand in the bunkers is inconsistent, and the greens are a tad slow, but I would happily choose the conditioning at WPB over so many of the over-watered, over-manicured, bright green courses for which Florida is known.

Clubhouse as seen from Putting Green
While I really enjoyed WPB, it is far from great.  Though there are no holes that are terrible, there are a good number that are very ordinary.  The sand bordering every fairway, can add interest to some of these holes, but really they are of little strategic interest.  Nevertheless, for $24.00 including cart on EZ Links (though I walked -- nice to have that option), I am convinced this is among the very best values in the entire country.

The routing is adequate -- easily walkable and with fairly effective use of the limited elevation on property, though there were a few too many holes that moved back-and-forth.

Green shaping is a highlight of the golf course, though green contouring is not.

Tee Marker with WPB Logo
Holes to Note
Hole 2: Par 5, 588 Yards
After a fairly benign opening hole, the golf course shows it teeth with the very long par-5 2nd.  The strong wind blows into the golfer from the left, making the fairly wide fairway difficult to find.  To find the fairway, one must aim at the bunker on the left and hope his ball blows into the centre of the fairway, and not so far that it finds the waste area on the right.  The golfer willing to sacrifice distance for accuracy can choose to hit his tee shot to the widest part of the fairway short of the bunkering on the left, but this will leave a second shot in the 350 yard area.  
2nd Tee
After a good tee shot, the second shot is as simple as any shot on the course.  Lots of width, just lay up to the yardage you want -- the second shot is the weak spot on this hole.
The 2nd at the 2nd
The approach is played slightly uphill to a green that slopes significantly back-to-front.  Two bunkers guard the green, with the one on the left being of some significant depth.
Approach to the 2nd
2nd from Behind Green
Hole 4: Par 4, 465 Yards
Though the 4th is long on the card and plays slightly uphill, it is the first time the player will have the wind with him -- downwind and with the firm fairways, this hole will play fairly short.  The 4th fairway is extremely wide.  The bunkering is a bit unusual, with an out-of-play bunker guarding the beginning of  the fairway on the right, and a bunker on the left guarding the ideal angle into the green.
4th Tee
This was the most fun approach on the golf course.    Playing straight downwind from 150 yards, and with a large 'kicker' short-right of the green, gauging the yardage is no easy task -- any shot flying onto the green probably will not stop.  A chipped 7-iron played up the slope on the right is very fun to watch it bounce, roll and trundle down onto the green -- what is this, Florida or Ireland?
Approach to the 4th -- Note kicker on the right
The 4th green among the best greens on the course -- narrow in front and wide in the back, full of small rolls and a more significant ridge separating the front of the green from the back.
4th Green
4th from Behind
Hole 5: Par 4, 326 Yards
Routed in the same direction as the 4th, the 5th also plays straight downwind and is driveable by the bombers.  For those willing to lay-back, short of the bunkers that juts into the fairway 80 yards short of the green, the fairway is extremely wide.  Golfers hoping to leave only a pitch into the green must challenge the narrow portion of the fairway right of the bunker.  The hole would be greatly improved if at least one of those front bunkers were removed to further entice players to try to drive the green.
5th Tee

5th Fairway - Note the Massive Width Short of the Bunker
5th Approach Short of Bunker
The pitch to the 5th is not so simple, playing uphill and straight downwind to a green that slopes away from the golfer.  Perhaps laying back in the fairway was the play?
5th from Behind Green
Hole 7: Par 3, 225 Yards
As a golfer who has seen many golf courses, when I see a 225 yard par-3 (200 yard from the member's tee), I expect it play downhill and/or downwind.  Not so at WPB! The 7th is a brute of a hole, playing uphill, into the wind, with massively deep bunkering and the most contoured green on the course!
7th Tee
Deep Bunkers Guard the Front of the 7th Green
The green has a very 'wavy' feel as ridges run through the green, separating it into three bowls and a pinnable and very difficult centre ridge.
7th Green
7th from Behind-Right
Hole 10: Par 5, 478 Yards
The 10th tee shot is a lesson in simple, strategic design -- challenge the bunker on the right for the shorter approach with the best angle, or play away from the bunker to the wide part of the fairway and leave a more difficult second shot.  If the bunker on the right is carried (about 280) yards, the player will find a significant downslope, which would make this par-5 look silly, leaving nothing more than 150 yards into the green.
10th Tee
Second shot on the 10th from Top of Hill -- Bunker on the Right is Bizarrely Placed
10th Green
The 10th green is dull -- large and simply contoured, and guarded only by two small front bunkers.  Or is it?  A view from the 11th green shows a deep run-off into the waste area long-left of the green -- don't miss there!
10th from 11th Green
Hole 12: Par 5, 518 Yards
The 12th is a great example of a hole with the 'bunkers everywhere' appearance.  Though the bunkers are staggered, and some of the bunkering is actually waste area some 400 yards from the tee, it appears as though there are bunkers no matter what the line off the tee.  Of the bunkers in play, the golfer must give the most consideration to the two bunkers that pinch the fairway 250 yards from the green -- lay-up to the them and reaching the green in two is impossible; challenge/carry them and the golfer catches a downslope and will have no more than 200 yards into the green.
12th Tee
12th Tee Zoomed In
For most, the second shot will be played from the top of the hill, short of the fairway bunkers.  The goal is to avoid the waste area on the right.  Lay-up as close to the green as you like, but beware, the fairway narrows the closer to the green the golfer gets.
12th Second Shot
The approach to the 12th is played over a front bunker and a very cool-looking grass bunker.
12th Approach
Grass Bunkers Short of 12th Green
The 12th green is very shallow and very sloped from back-to-front.  The green-shape is very interesting, resembling a, well, you can work it out...
12 Green
12th from Behind Green
Hole 17: Par 4, 388 Yards
The 17th is a decent mid-length par-4, but I think it could be a very good short par-4 if you move up a set (or two) of tees as I did.  The pictures are taken from the 350 yard tee box.  From there, there is a real decision whether to play to the wide portion of the right, or to challenge the bunker on the left to leave just a pitch into the green.
17th Tee
17th Tee Zoomed In
The approach to the 17th is fairly simple provided the golfer is coming from the fairway.  Boring bunkering.
17th Approach
17th from Behind -- Note 'Sunday Pin Position" on Left Edge of Green
Hole 18: Par 5, 565 Yards
The tee shot at the 18th is a fairly difficult one.  The fairway is narrower than many others on the course, though perhaps this is because the hole generally plays straight downwind.
18th Tee
The golfer must choose whether to play to the wide part of the fairway on the left, or to carry the waste area on the right for the ideal line to lay up or go for the green.
18th Tee Zoomed In
The second shot is played over the corner of the fairway bunker, with the main goal of avoiding the fairway bunker on the right side of the fairway, 100 yards short of the green.
18th Second Shot
The approach to the 18th is played to yet another raised green, guarded by bunkers short left and right.
18th Approach
18th from Behind